The 2015 Willie M Medal: Round 3

Filed in NRL, Willie M by on March 23, 2015

South Sydney may have won the premiership last year and every bit of silverware since – and they may be undefeated through three weeks – but they face a mammoth task winning the title again with Joel Reddy in the team. Few players are as incompetent  as Reddy, who seems to be Michael Maguire’s self-employed handicap. If he keeps his spot in first grade, he will win the Willie M Medal.

Manly v Canterbury
3-Justin Horo (Man)
2-Daly Cherry-Evans (Man)
1-Tom Symonds (Man)
Judge: Nick Tedeschi

Brisbane v North Queensland
3-Justin O’Neill (NQ)
2-James Tamou (NQ)
1-Adam Blair (Bri)
Judge: Craig Finlayson

New Zealand v Parramatta
3-Chris Sandow (Par)
2-Isaac De Gois (Par)
1-Brad Takairangi (Par)
Judge: Rohan Kendall

Canberra v St George Illawarra
3-Gareth Widdop (Dra)
2-Blake Austin (Can)
1-Jarryd Kennedy (Can)
Judge: Rohan Kendall

Melbourne v Cronulla
3-Gerard Beale (Cro)
2-Michael Gordon (Cro)
1-Ben Barba (Cro)
Judge: Nathan Boss

Souths v Wests Tigers
3-Joel Reddy (Sou)
2-Pat Richards (Tig)
1-George Burgess (Sou)
Judge: Nick Tedeschi

Gold Coast v Newcastle
3-Daniel Mortimer (GC)
2-Joey Leilua (New)
1-Dave Taylor (GC)
Judge: Nick Tedeschi

Sydney Roosters v Penrith
3-James Segeyaro (Pen)
2-Shaun Kenny-Dowall (Roo)
1-Isaac John (Pen)
Judge: Nick Tedeschi

7: Ben Barba (Cro)
6: Justin O’Neill (NQ)
5: Joel Reddy (Sou), Shaun Kenny-Dowall (Roo)
4: Jordan McLean (Mel), Brad Takairangi (Par)


Comments (4)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Jazzy John says:

    Im a dogs fan and loathe manly but how can you give DCE 2 points when he was involved in 2 of the 3 manly tries? Pick up your game nick, don’t let your personal views cloud your judgement!

  2. ct says:

    if you talk incompetence – take a look at how many wild passes Pearce did last nite. just flung out the back to no one. . Always trys to offload fast so he doesnt hit the grass. Back to his true form. While im at it – he is the master of the forward pass and gets away with it most weeks. how many tries did roosters have last yr off forward passes? 8 to 10? Never a word against him from fox sport commentators.

  3. madpunter says:

    Can I elaborate on how you grade the player ratings for the willie m? How did segyaro rate so poorly or do you have to top rank 3 players from each match?

    • borm loser says:

      Maybe Nick lost his doh having Segyaro for the first try scorer – I did. Shoulda give him 4 points!