From The Couch: Round 8

Filed in Uncategorized by on May 5, 2019

From The Couch: Round 8

Night of the Long Knives: Chris and Lynne Anderson have been patient. They’ve waited. They’ve talked to the right people. They’ve bided their time. They have consolidated power. And now they have moved, sacking four key football staff including Football Manager Gareth Holmes and Team Manager Andrew Farrar. It comes after only a token one-year extension of Dean Pay’s contract. The team continues to work through the salary cap debacle left in their lap by Des Hasler, Raelene Castle and Ray Dib. Make no mistake – this was a critical purge of staff who, for the most part, were viewed as part of the old regime. This is about clearing the decks and setting in motion the strategy for a new era, one that will help put to an end Canterbury’s long premiership drought. The Andersons know Rugby League but they also know what they don’t know and that is pretty important as they look to steer the ship right for the first time in a long time.

Never Mess with The Master: Wayne Bennett is the very best when it comes to getting the mental edge over another coach. The only bloke it hasn’t really worked on is Craig Bellamy and that is because Bellamy doesn’t give a damn. Anthony Seibold is the latest to make a run at Bennett. He angled for the Broncos job, then cracked it publicly when Bennett wouldn’t walk away and has since been sulking as the Broncos have gone from bad to worse. He had his big chance at revenge and Bennett put him in his place. He did so in the lead-in with his interviews and press conferences. He did so with the result. The highlight was Bennett supposedly kicking all non-players out of the dressing room and thanking them for what they did for him before going to a press conference and telling the world it didn’t mean anything. The Master.

The Warriors are Just The Warriors: The Warriors just cannot stop being the Warriors. No matter what positive steps forward they make as an organisation, they continue to mess everything up with ridiculous personnel calls. Just a few years on from signing Adam Blair to a contract probably 10 times his worth, they have gone out and recruited Kodi Nikorima. The same Kodi Nikorima who was on the outs at a Brisbane team that were giving nothing. They have decided to pay him in the vicinity of $700,000 a season. This comes around six months after telling Shaun Johnson – a former Golden Boot winner and one of the club’s greatest all-time players – that they would not pay him a million per. It is a decision that defies belief except it doesn’t at all.

Playing Out of Position: Five players that are being played out of position out of either necessity or stupidity.

Moses Mbye – Should be a hooker. Has too many mistakes and lacks the speed to be a fullback.

Jack Wighton – Ricky made the right move to get him out of the fullback position but his best go is at centre.

Josh Dugan – The only place he can be played is at wing. He cannot pass so is useless as a fullback or a centre.

Kodi Nikorima – Not a halfback by any stretch. Is a hooker out-and-out.

Tyrone Peachey – He is far too exposed defensively at centre while he doesn’t get enough ball. He would be better at five-eighth getting more protection in defence.

2019 Field Goal Update – 13: No field goals in Round 8 though we did see Cameron Munster attempt one of the more insane shots.

Fun Fact #1: No coach got fired mid-season in the 1960s

Fun Fact #2: The first coach to lose their job mid-season was Mike Stephenson in 1975, who left his post as captain-coach of the Panthers 16 games into the year. A week later Clive Churchill quit as Souths coach. Barry Harris and Bob McCarthy took over the Panthers and Rabbitohs respectively.

Fun Fact #3: Coaches sacked mid-season in the 1980s: Greg Hawick (Norths, 1985), Laurie Freier (Wests, 1988).

Betting Market of the Week: Bryce Cartwright’s best secret to winning Rugby League games:

$1.70: Unexpected flick passes to nobody on the first tackle
$2.30: Refusing to tackle
$3.00: Spreading contagious and once contained diseases to the wider populace

Rumour Mill: Phil Gould has been linked to a shock move to Canterbury to run the football operations at the club he coached to the 1988 title. He left the club on far from the best terms though and it would be a surprise to see the Andersons cede such power. Cameron Smith has been rumoured to be considering an Origin comeback to help the injury-ravaged Maroons. Manly are now favourites to sign Clint Gutherson. Jayden Brailey has been linked with a move to Newcastle.

Game of the Year Nomination, Round 8: Cronulla – Melbourne, 20 – 18.

Random Fact of Rugby League Stupidity: Leo Abberton, who played three games for Glebe and Balmain in 1925-26, is the first premiership player when it comes to alphabetical order. Trevor Allan, who coached Norths in 1957-58, is the first coach.

Moronic Coaching Decision of the Week: Any coach that can play Darius Boyd in first grade, let alone name him captain, has lost the plot. Aging players go through form ruts. Few stop trying though. Boyd has done just that. He is putting in no effort in what is one of the most disgraceful showings I can recall seeing. The first three tries he refused to dive on two loose balls that he was first at before refusing to chase an intercept. Last Thursday was his 300th game. It should be his last.

The Coaching Crosshairs: Garth Brennan is a dead man walking at the Titans and it would not surprise at all to see him axed in the next few weeks. The team plays like it has not been coached. There is a terribly low football IQ, a total lack of creativity in attack and a failure of so many to understand what looks to be even the most basic concepts. Mal Meninga joined the club clearly to slide his way back into the NRL and taking over as an interim coach seems a good way of dipping his toe in without committing.

Beard Watch: It is not often you see a kid debut with a full-fledged beard but that is what we saw from new Manly winger Abbas Miski, who looked like Josh Mansour in a Manly jumper.

Correspondence Corner: Cowboys might collapse as a club under Panthers ex-fullbacks, Andrew Quinn.

Joey, thanks for the vision of the shoutout. Good man is Crash.

Paul Robertson, what’s the AFL? I agree re: different finances but I can’t imagine the costs would be significant and if they are, then they need to think about how the framework is set up because there needs to be punishments for outright deceiving the public. Would this be allowed from a spokesman of a publicly listed company or would there be major fines?

Knight Vision, not sure anybody deserves that much time. In fact I don’t think any coach deserves anything. You get what you offer and can negotiate. He has clearly done a good job on that front.

Kel, no comment because I was about 54 beers deep by the time kickoff came around and memories of the game are sketchy at best.

Watch It: For reasons of we can, this week we go and look at the 1980 BRL preliminary final between Norths and Valleys. The Devils and Diehards featured some greats as well as plenty of cult heroes including Wally Lewis, Mark Graham, Joe Kilroy, Graham Lowe, Ross Strudwick, Greg Conescu and referee Eddie Ward. Let’s not go past Billy J Smith’s tremendous job as host and chief caller. Watch it here.

Comments (11)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Davey G says:

    I wonder if it just a bandwagon thing when commentators suggest and when coaches move a good player to the halves. I always liked Matt Moylan at fullback, but then he went to the halves. They tried Hayne in the halves (well, that WAS Ricky Sturart who has done it again with Wighton), and there are plenty of examples. Latrell Mitchell is currently tearing other teams a new arse in the centres, and in my book if it ain’t broke, you don’t fix it, so why does he need to move into the halves when he is the best centre in the game? Crazy talk – especially for the Roosters who will have dubloons to spare when Cronk retires so can just grab any good player from anywhere they like.

    I guess it worked both ways, like when they put Joey into hooker for Origin (so they could put Kimmorley in the halves – BAHAHAHAHA) or even putting Brett Kenny (God) in the centres for the green and gold.

    • Davey G says:

      Just quickly – now that Eels have been belted, the Parramatta board need to make the call. Either they are going to keep Brad Arthur or they don’t want to. There’s no more “let’s see how he goes”, because it’s clear he can coach the team he has to about a 5th to12th-ish position, so make the call so King Gutho and others can do the same.

  2. Robbo says:

    Yes, I agree that a quality framework should not be hugely expensive. It does depend on who within the executive ranks has the ear of the Board and also the Board members themselves. In my view the more the Board gets dominated by the clubs, as has been the strong trend, the less they’ll be inclined to implement something that will make the clubs accountable.

    In the vast majority of cases, public companies will only disclose what they must by legislation. Therefore, for items like these to be seriously considered the responsibility of the Board as a governor over clubs is important. I just don’t see the NRL Board has having that type of authority any more (if it ever did).

  3. Knight Vision says:

    correct about Darius Boyd , he’s doing what he did at Newcastle so it is nothing about age and all about poor Darius isnt happy. His best days are behind him and Bennett signed him to a huge deal. I’m interested to see what mess Bennett made of the Broncos cap before he left. I’m betting some of the young Bronco kids are on big money and theyve got little room under the cap, thats just the way Bennett roles.

    • ctpe says:

      why would Bennett put them in a salary cap hole when he wanted to stay and didn’t leave the club until December?

  4. Joey says:

    Even Blind Freddie can see Darius has thrown in the towel, but the Broncos are stuck between a rock and a hard place on where to go from here as he has 3 years @ $800k per season left on his contract…..

    Here’s hoping Crash Craddock’s nickname of ‘scholarly punter’ he gave you takes off!!

  5. ctpe says:

    Will Bulldogs fans blaming Hasler last longer then Parra fans blaming Fitzgerald?

    Hasler didn’t sign Dylan Napa. Hasler didn’t sign a Newcastle reserve grader to play in the halves. Hasler didn’t appoint Dean Pay. Hasler isn’t designing a game plan that results in 13 points a game

    Hasler seems to be doing ok at Manly, where a fair chunk of his salary cap is sitting in the stands. He has Elgey and Croker taking turns at 5/8, two centres who would start at any other team in the 8, and Curtis Sironen

    Maybe it was the club, not the coach

  6. Cam says:

    The footage of the Brisbane comp was fantastic but very sad. It shows that the broncos thing is a crock. This is what Brisbane gave up when the broncos took over, and I’d say that we would have a proper conference system by now if that hadn’t occurred.

    Your average broncos fan doesn’t even realise what they have lost.

    • Mav63 says:

      I was there that day and as a loyal Valleys man I know what we lost. We lost history and some wonderful clubs. I’m also a broncos supporter so I can see both sides but yes with the talent in the BRL at the time we could have had a strong two state conference